2. Systems Engineering

2.4 Products of Design Reference Missions

Cover photo of Human Exploration of Mars Design Reference Architecture 5.0 by Mars Architecture Steering Group at NASA Headquarters and Bret G. Drake, editor at NASA Johnson Space Center, Houston, Texas.

A design reference mission (DRM) “establishes an operational context, descriptions of the environment and situations in which solution concepts are expected to operate, an operational narrative of expected behavior including a sequence of operational activities and interactions between systems in an environment, and sample measures for establishing goals for mission success” [Giammarco and Shebalin].

DRMs are “critical tools at the mission level for evaluating potential architectural concepts. Without a well-thought-out DRM, a conceptual mission design is at risk for not optimizing system trades, identifying necessary technology development, managing resources, and achieving a balanced design. The DRM provides traceability from science objectives to engineering requirements and can be used to examine options and implications for observations; find “tall poles” and drivers and identify the ultimate limits of performance. In this manner, it is a crucial tool for recognizing and nourishing the major strengths of the observatory and ranking design drivers. The DRM is used as a guide and referee for major “big picture” trades such as orbit selection, schedule availability and scheduling approaches for operations, and time-to-complete the DRM as a metric for observational efficiency” [Lightsey and Wilkinson].

The DRM could take the form of a narrative, storyboard, pictogram, timeline, or combination thereof and is created by eventual users of the system (“stakeholders”) very early in the development cycle [Akin]. An immense DRM for reference is the Human Exploration of Mars Design Reference Architecture 5.0 and addendum.

Quote by Ray Bradbury, Mars, and the Mind Man. Image courtesy of NASA.

Concept of Operations

A concept of operations is a “description of how the proposed system will accomplish the design reference mission(s) and will appear to be similar to DRM but is a product of the design, rather than a driving requirement” [Akin]. A concept of operations is commonly shortened to ConOps, derived from DoD origins. ConOps samples include a Lunar Reconnaissance OrbiterGeostationary Operational Environmental Satellites (GOES-R), Ice Home Mars Habitat, and Sentinel-1 Satellite. There exist plenty of infographics of current and proposed ConOps by sifting through a Google Image search.  A concept of operations that is feasible with the Artemis CubeSat Kit is a proposed Ke Ao mission.

Phases of Ke Ao. Image courtesy of HSFL.

Ke Ao CubeSat ConOps

  • Ke Ao is a 1U CubeSat with a similar purpose as the Artemis CubeSat Kit, designed by undergraduate students from the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa. Its mission is to take a picture of Hawaiʻi from space and be the first iteration of the HiCubeSat Kit – an educational and research kit with the goal of creating and promoting aerospace workforce training and education in Hawaii.
    Exploded view of Ke Ao. Image courtesy of Hawaii Space Flight Laboratory.
  • Ke Ao’s Concept of Operations can be broken up into four phases:
    • Phase 1 (Launch Phase): Ke Ao will be launched to the ISS, then get deployed into orbit and powered on.
    • Phase 2 (Charge Phase): Once Ke Ao is in orbit, the batteries to power the Ke Ao system will be charged via solar panels.
    • Phase 3 (Alignment Phase): Ke Ao’s Attitude Determination and Control System will orient the satellite such that it is pointing at Earth so that the Payload camera can take a picture of Hawaii.
    • Phase 4 (Viewing Phase): Ke Ao will take a picture, and then transfer data to its Ground Station at Kauai Community College.
    • Phase 5 (Transmit/Communication Phase) The picture will be taken and stored, but may not be sent until a later time.  This is where the radio sends the picture and other data to the ground station.
  • During Ke Ao’s lifetime, it will repeat Phases 2, 3, and 4 in space.

Space Systems Architecture

A space systems architecture is a “description of physical hardware, processes, and operations to perform DRM” [Akin]. The space systems architecture “can be broken down into main three physical parts: the space segment, the launch segment, and the ground segment. The space segment can be either a single satellite or a constellation of satellites in the same or multiple orbits. The launch segment can be relatively simple for a single satellite architecture, or very intricate for a many-satellite architecture (like Iridium, or GPS). The ground segment often includes a choice of whether to use data downlink gateway systems in space (i.e. TDRSS) or on the earth (i.e. the Deep Space Network, or AFSCN) ” [Weigel].

Ground system examples. Image by Space Systems.

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

A Guide to CubeSat Mission and Bus Design Copyright © by Frances Zhu is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book